Are ETFs really better than mutual funds?
The choice comes down to what you value most. If you prefer the flexibility of trading intraday and favor lower expense ratios in most instances, go with ETFs. If you worry about the impact of commissions and spreads, go with mutual funds.
Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) take the benefits of mutual fund investing to the next level. ETFs can offer lower operating costs than traditional open-end funds, flexible trading, greater transparency, and better tax efficiency in taxable accounts.
“And they are incredibly cheap.” However, there are disadvantages of ETFs. They come with fees, can stray from the value of their underlying asset, and (like any investment) come with risks. So it's important for any investor to understand the downside of ETFs.
Mutual funds are usually actively managed, although passively-managed index funds have become more popular. ETFs are usually passively managed and track a market index or sector sub-index. ETFs can be bought and sold just like stocks, while mutual funds can only be purchased at the end of each trading day.
There are many ways an ETF can stray from its intended index. That tracking error can be a cost to investors. Indexes do not hold cash but ETFs do, so a certain amount of tracking error in an ETF is expected. Fund managers generally hold some cash in a fund to pay administrative expenses and management fees.
In addition, ETFs tend to have much lower expense ratios compared to actively managed funds, can be more tax-efficient, and offer the option to immediately reinvest dividends. Still, unique risks can arise from holding ETFs as well as tax considerations, depending on the type of ETF.
The single biggest risk in ETFs is market risk. Like a mutual fund or a closed-end fund, ETFs are only an investment vehicle—a wrapper for their underlying investment. So if you buy an S&P 500 ETF and the S&P 500 goes down 50%, nothing about how cheap, tax efficient, or transparent an ETF is will help you.
If you're paying fees for a fund with a high expense ratio or paying too much in taxes each year because of undesired capital gains distributions, switching to ETFs is likely the right choice.
Should you invest in ETFs? Since ETFs offer built-in diversification and don't require large amounts of capital in order to invest in a range of stocks, they are a good way to get started. You can trade them like stocks while also enjoying a diversified portfolio.
| Exchange-traded fund (ticker) | Assets under management | Yield |
|---|---|---|
| Vanguard 500 Index ETF (VOO) | $406.2 billion | 1.4% |
| Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF (VIG) | $75.6 billion | 1.9% |
| Vanguard U.S. Quality Factor ETF (VFQY) | $298.0 million | 1.4% |
| SPDR Gold MiniShares (GLDM) | $6.1 billion | 0.0% |
What is 1 benefit and 1 drawback of an ETF compared to a mutual fund?
| ETFs | Mutual Funds | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Determined by market | Net asset value (NAV) |
| Tax Efficiency | Usually tax efficient due to less turnover and fewer capital gains | Not as tax efficient due to more turnover and greater capital gains |
| Automatic Investing | Not available | Yes, for investments and withdrawals |
| Symbol | Name | 5-Year Return |
|---|---|---|
| VGT | Vanguard Information Technology ETF | 22.83% |
| XHB | SPDR S&P Homebuilders ETF | 22.67% |
| IXN | iShares Global Tech ETF | 22.57% |
| IETC | iShares U.S. Tech Independence Focused ETF | 22.15% |
Usually, ETFs have much lower fees and higher daily liquidity compared to mutual fund shares. ETF can be used for purposes like Hedging, Equitizing Cash, and for Arbitrage. ETF shareholders get a small portion of the gained profits, i.e, the dividends paid and interest earned.
| Mutual Funds | ETFs | |
|---|---|---|
| Trades executed: | Once per day, after market close | Throughout the trading day and during extended hours trading |
| Settlement period: | From 1 to 2 business days | 2 business days (trade date + 2) |
| Short sales allowed? | No | Yes |
| Limit and stop orders allowed? | No | Yes |
Short-Term Products
Investors can hold the ETF for longer than a day, but returns can vary significantly from 2x exposure over longer periods. That's because the ETF resets its leverage daily. In oscillating markets, the leverage reset can significantly erode returns.
Too much diversification can dilute performance
Adding new ETFs to a portfolio that includes this Energy ETF would decrease its performance. Since the allocation to the Energy ETF will naturally decrease - and so will its contribution to the total portfolio return.
ETF benefits, including simplicity, low expenses and tax efficiency, make exchange-traded funds a worthwhile investment for retirement. Popular types of ETFs for retirement include dividend ETFs, fixed-income ETFs and real estate ETFs.
Are ETFs or Index Funds Safer? Neither an ETF nor an index fund is safer than the other because it depends on what the fund owns.45 Stocks will always be riskier than bonds but will usually yield higher returns on investment.
ETFs are generally considered more tax-efficient than mutual funds, owing to the fact that they typically have fewer capital gains distributions. However, they still have tax implications you must consider, both when creating your portfolio as well as when timing the sale of an ETF you hold.
You expose your portfolio to much higher risk with sector ETFs, so you should use them sparingly, but investing 5% to 10% of your total portfolio assets may be appropriate. If you want to be highly conservative, don't use these at all.
Is it better to invest in individual stocks or ETFs?
Stock-picking offers an advantage over exchange-traded funds (ETFs) when there is a wide dispersion of returns from the mean. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) offer advantages over stocks when the return from stocks in the sector has a narrow dispersion around the mean.
The administrative costs of managing ETFs are commonly lower than those for mutual funds. ETFs keep their administrative and operational expenses down through market-based trading. Because ETFs are bought and sold on the open market, the sale of shares from one investor to another does not affect the fund.
Generally speaking, the best time to trade ETFs is closer to the middle of the trading day rather than the beginning or end.
If the mutual fund returns have been poor over a period of less than a year, liquidating your holdings in the portfolio may not be the best idea since the mutual fund may simply be experiencing some short-term fluctuations.
ETFs still perform well and can even beat out stocks and hands-on investors with very little effort on your part. You should still be willing to research different ETF options, but you don't have to be so concerned about picking “winners” as such.
